Car Rental In Islamorada Florida Keys

Welcome to RentalGuideFlorida – Your Ultimate Resource for Car Rental In Islamorada Florida Keys in the Sunshine State

Florida Car Rentals

Islamorada, known as the “Village of Islands,” lies in the heart of the Florida Keys and is renowned for its clear blue waters, excellent fishing, and laid-back atmosphere. It’s a destination where the pace of life slows down, and the natural beauty takes center stage. While public transportation options in the Keys can be limited, renting a car provides the freedom to explore Islamorada and its surrounding areas at your own pace. Here’s how to navigate the process of securing a car rental in Islamorada for a hassle-free vacation.

Finding a Car Rental in Islamorada, Florida Keys

1. Explore Local and Regional Options: While Islamorada may have a few car rental agencies, you’ll find a broader selection at Key West International Airport and Miami International Airport. Many travelers choose to fly into Miami, rent a car, and enjoy the scenic drive down to the Keys via the Overseas Highway (U.S. 1).

2. Book in Advance: To ensure the best selection and rates, it’s wise to book your car rental well in advance, especially during peak travel seasons like summer, spring break, or winter holidays when demand is high.

3. Use Comparison Websites: Utilize car rental comparison websites to quickly compare rates and options from multiple companies. This can help you find the best deal suited to your needs.

4. Review Rental Policies: Each rental company has its policies regarding insurance, fuel, mileage, and drop-off locations. Ensure you understand these policies to avoid any unexpected charges.

5. Consider Your Needs: Think about the type of vehicle that will best suit your travel plans. Compact cars are easier to navigate and park, but if you’re planning on bringing gear for fishing, diving, or other activities, you might need an SUV or a vehicle with ample trunk space.

Tips for a Smooth Car Rental Experience in Islamorada

  • Insurance: Check if your personal car insurance or credit card offers coverage for rental cars, which can save you money on additional insurance from the rental company.
  • Driving in the Keys: The Overseas Highway is a two-lane road with speed limits varying between 35-55 mph. Patience is key, especially during high traffic times. Always observe speed limits and be mindful of cyclists and pedestrians.
  • Parking: Make sure to understand the parking arrangements at your accommodation. Some places offer free parking, while others might have restrictions or fees.
  • Fuel Policy: Familiarize yourself with the rental company’s fuel policy. The most common policy is ‘full-to-full,’ where you receive the car with a full tank and are expected to return it full.

Enjoying Islamorada with Your Rental Car

Having a car in Islamorada opens up a world of possibilities. Drive down to Robbie’s Marina to feed the tarpons, explore the beautiful Anne’s Beach, or take a day trip to Key West to experience its vibrant streets and historic sites. The freedom of having a car lets you discover the lesser-known gems of the Florida Keys at your leisure.


Renting a car in Islamorada, Florida Keys, enhances your vacation by providing the freedom to explore the islands on your terms. With careful planning and consideration of the tips provided, you can enjoy a smooth rental experience and an unforgettable trip to this tropical paradise.

Travel Smarter: Tips, Guides and Great Deals: